Fishing at Keuka Lake: A Guide for Anglers in the Finger Lakes
Depot Park, Hammondsport NYKeuka Lake, one of the most picturesque and unique of the Finger Lakes, is a haven for anglers of all levels. Known for its distinctive Y-shape, clear waters, and abundant fish species, Keuka Lake offers a rich fishing experience year-round. Whether you're casting from the shore, trolling from a boat, or ice fishing in the winter, this guide will help you make the most of your fishing adventure at Keuka Lake.
Fish Keuka Lake
The Fish of Keuka Lake Keuka Lake is home to a diverse array of fish species, making it a popular destination for anglers. Some of the most sought-after fish include:
Lake Trout: The most famous resident of Keuka Lake, Lake Trout can be found at depths ranging from 60 to 200 feet. They’re typically caught by trolling with downriggers or vertical jigging.
Smallmouth Bass: Known for their fighting spirit, Smallmouth Bass are often found near rocky shores, drop-offs, and around submerged structures.
Yellow Perch: A favorite among ice fishers, Yellow Perch are abundant in Keuka Lake and can be caught using small jigs, worms, or minnows.
Brown Trout: Typically found in cooler, deeper waters, Brown Trout are a prized catch, especially in the early spring and late fall.
Landlocked Atlantic Salmon: Although less common, these salmon can be caught in the lake, offering a unique fishing challenge.
Panfish: Bluegill, Pumpkinseed, and Crappie are abundant in the shallow areas of the lake, making them ideal for family fishing trips.
Keuka Lake Fishing
Best Times to Fish
Spring (April-June): As the water warms, fish become more active. Lake Trout are abundant, and Smallmouth Bass fishing picks up as they move into shallower waters to spawn.
Summer (July-August): Early morning and late evening are the best times to fish in the summer heat. Lake Trout retreat to deeper waters, while bass and panfish can be found near drop-offs and shaded areas.
Fall (September-November): Fall is prime time for catching trophy-sized Lake Trout and Brown Trout as they prepare for the colder months. The cooling water also brings bass back to shallower areas.
Winter (December-March): Ice fishing is a popular winter activity on Keuka Lake. Yellow Perch and Lake Trout are the main targets, and several access points around the lake provide safe entry onto the ice.
Where to Fish
Shore Fishing: The shores of Keuka Lake are dotted with public parks and fishing areas, such as Keuka Lake State Park and the Penn Yan Boat Launch. These spots offer easy access to prime fishing locations.
Boat Fishing: Renting a boat or bringing your own allows you to explore the deeper sections of the lake where Lake Trout and Brown Trout thrive. Marinas such as Basin Park Marina and Keuka Watersports offer boat rentals and services.
Ice Fishing: Popular ice fishing spots include the north and south ends of the lake, particularly around Hammondsport and Branchport. Ensure the ice is at least 4 inches thick before venturing out.
Tackle and Gear Recommendations
Lake Trout: Use downriggers with spoons or flashers and flies for trolling at depth. Vertical jigging with white or silver jigs can also be effective.
Smallmouth Bass: Medium to light spinning tackle with soft plastics, crankbaits, or live bait works well near rocky structures.
Yellow Perch: Light tackle with small jigs tipped with worms, minnows, or soft plastics are ideal.
Ice Fishing: For Lake Trout, use tip-ups with live minnows, and for Yellow Perch, small jigs or spoons.
Local Tips
Early Morning and Late Evening: These are the best times to fish, as many species are more active during these cooler periods.
Watch the Weather: Fish activity can change with the weather. Overcast days are often better for fishing than bright, sunny ones.
Check Local Reports: Before heading out, check local fishing reports or talk to the staff at bait and tackle shops for the latest information on where the fish are biting.